Prime News Ghana

Substitute subbed- was Everton's Kean harshly treated?

By Mutala Yakubu
Everton interim boss Duncan Ferguson did not look at Moise Kean after substituting the striker
Everton interim boss Duncan Ferguson did not look at Moise Kean after substituting the striker
facebook sharing button Share
twitter sharing button Tweet
email sharing button Email
sharethis sharing button Share

When Moise Kean's number was held up by the fourth official in the final minutes of Everton's 1-1 draw with Manchester United at Old Trafford, the Italian striker looked completely baffled.

After all, he had only been on the pitch for 18 minutes.

Brought on in the 70th minute, taken off in the 88th, Kean appeared to be blanked by Everton interim boss Duncan Ferguson as the 19-year-old made his way off the pitch and towards the tunnel.

Shortly after the full-time whistle was blown, Ferguson was asked why he decided to substitute the substitute.

"I just needed to make a substitution to kill a bit of time," he said.

READ ALSO: EPL: Man City spanks Arsenal at Emirates, Man United drop more points at home

"I have a lot of attackers on the bench, it was nothing against him personally."

Facing the media in the post-match news conference later, Ferguson expanded a little more: "I thought he had not quite got into the pace of the game.

"We put on a guy [Oumar Niasse] that handles it better. Nothing about Moise. I've been there, I've been subbed off but we'll pick him up, he'll come again, he's only 19."

Just how off the pace was Kean?

In the 18 minutes he was on he did not manage a shot of any type. Not particularly great for a striker and especially one still searching for his first goal for the club but then Everton were, at that point, under pressure from the hosts and instead holding out for a point rather than going for a win.

In terms of his general play, Kean had nine touches of the ball - the fewest of any player until his replacement, Niasse, came on for the final two minutes and touched the ball four times.

Moise Kean

Kean won none of his five duels with Manchester United players, and lost the ball six times while making no tackles.

Niasse, in contrast, won 50% of his duels and did not lose possession once while making two tackles - as many as centre-back Michael Keane.

Those statistics perhaps justify the tactical reasoning behind the change, but what do you think?


'For me, it was the wrong call'

Former Everton defender Joleon Lescott criticised the decision.

He told Sky Sports: "Yeah, that's tough to take as an individual. He's a young player as well. For me, it was the wrong call.

"I know after the game he said it wasn't about his performances but the fact he didn't shake his hand after the game makes me believe it was something about his performance that he didn't like."

Ex-Manchester City midfielder Michael Brown, co-commentating on the game for BBC Radio 5 Live, added: "Clearly Moise Kean can't have been following the instructions he was given because you can always tell.

"If it had been tactical, Duncan Ferguson would have had a little word with him but he completely ignored him."

'Mismanaged and embarrassed'

Nevertheless it was a decision that didn't go down particularly well with some people on social media...

Moise Kean
Moise Kean
Moise Kean tweet
Moise Kean tweet
Moise Kean tweet

When the substitute is substituted

It will be of little comfort for Kean but he is not the first substitute to himself be substituted later in the same game...

Juan Mata in the 2016 Community Shield
Juan Mata looked less than impressed when he was substituted in the 93rd minute of the 2016 Community Shield against Leicester City He had come on in the 63rd minute and was taken off in the 93rd, with then Manchester United boss Jose Mourinho saying: "He was the shortest player on the pitch, and more high balls were coming into the box." United won the game 2-1.
Aaron Lennon replaces David Beckham
In the quarter-final of the 2006 World Cup, a then 19-year-old Aaron Lennon came on for David Beckham before later being replaced by Jamie Carragher, who was brought on for the penalty shootout. England lost the spot kicks.
Nemanja Matic
Mourinho certainly appears to love substituting a substitute. This time it was Nemanja Matic who got the early hook after coming on. He lasted 30 minutes after climbing off the bench at half-time while playing for Chelsea against Southampton in 2015. The game was 1-1 when he came on and 3-1 to the Saints when he went off.
Source: BBC